I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (2024)

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (1)

Sauce Down

Zaxby’s is known for its fast-food fried chicken, but a closer look beneath the hood will reveal that Zax actually has something worth bragging about. With 13 sauces on offer for its chicken fingers and other specialties, there is definitely something special happening at Zaxby’s in the sauce department.

Not sure which one to grab for your chicken wings? Though I couldn’t get my hands on Insane Sauce (the hottest dipping sauce), here are the remaining 12 Zaxby’s sauces, ranked by taste and flavor.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (2)

Best: Sweet and Spicy Sauce

I am a sucker for sweet chili glaze. The stuff hits for me every time. Zaxby’s has cooked up a tasty one; sweet as honey, spicy enough to even it out, and threaded together by a healthy dose of sesame oil. Umami all around. There’s not a lot I wouldn’t dip into this. It’s the best Zaxby’s sauce by a mile.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (3)

2. Tongue Torch Sauce

Though I take issue with the suggestion that a sauce this mild might torch somebody’s tongue, I really like the flavor. This is just good hot sauce, no two ways about it. It’s piquant, spicy, and just sticky enough to cling to chicken and fries. If the Z-Man wanted to turn up the heat a little bit, I wouldn’t complain.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (4)

3. Teriyaki Sauce

I fully did not expect the sauce ranking of a southern fried chicken chain to have two Asian-style sauces in the Top 3. Zaxby’s teriyaki sauce is actually really good; tangy, smoky, and sticky. Fast-food teriyaki sauce is highly inconsistent, but this is a strong recipe on Zaxby’s part.

For more fast food reviews,please sign up for our free newsletters.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (5)

4. Buffalo Garlic Blaze

The name says it all. We’ve got ourselves a creamy, orange Buffalo sauce with a liberal amount of garlic. I like the extra kick quite a bit, and the thickness is perfect for sticking to whatever’s being dipped into it.

Related:All 9 Popeyes Sauces, Ranked From Best to Worst

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (6)

5. Hot Honey Mustard Sauce

Not a bad idea in theory, but in practice it doesn’t hit as hard as it should. This is probably an if-it-ain’t-broke-don’t-fix-it situation, but combining hot honey and mustard is interesting. Or, on the other hand, a sweetened version of a hot Chinese mustard also sounds like a sauce I’d be into.

This is neither. It’s good, but I can’t help but shake the feeling that it should be great.

Related:I Ranked 8 McDonald’s Dipping Sauces — Including 2 Brand New Ones

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (7)

6. Nuclear Sauce

Zax. My dude. You gotta stop building up the sauces to be these scary, spicy monsters. Nuclear? No chance. This is a tasty, definitely spicy sauce, but nuclear feels like a little much. This isn’t too different from Tabasco with a little bit of ground pepper.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (8)

7. BBQ Sauce

It’s fine. Thick and smoky, sure, but you’ve got six much stronger options. Zaxby, that rat, is charging 25 cents per sauce, so make your selections count.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (9)

8. Honey Mustard Sauce

I considered that I’m being pranked. This really tastes like nothing. I was minutes away from grabbing a COVID test. This is some of the most bland honey mustard I’ve ever had in fast food, so if you’re a true fan of honey mustard, look elsewhere.There's probably a Bojangles nearby.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (10)

9. Wimpy Sauce

This is a great sauce for people that don’t like sauce. It’s the consistency and flavor profile of a vinegar-style pepper sauce, but there’s no heat. The ketchupy liquid is odd and empty without the heat. Dip your food in it if you’d like to strip away as much flavor as possible.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (11)

10. Ranch Sauce

I'm a huge snob when it comes to ranch dressing.You really need to bring your A-game to impress me with ranch, and this is C-game at best. This ranch is very mild and far too watery. You’ll never get wings to stick to it, and I fear that if it were spread on a chicken sandwich it would just come pouring out of the bun.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (12)

11. Zax Sauce

When you’re slinging 12 sauces, you’re gonna have some high highs and some low lows. Yet through all of the sauce-making Zaxby's has put itself through, this is the one it wants to stamp its name on. The signature sauce, if you will.

Bad call, 'cause this one's a stinker. Zax Sauce is in the same vein as a classic special sauce or thousand island, but far more eggy and thick. Has it been mixed with ranch? Who's to say. There’s a fair amount of black pepper floating in there as well. Across the board, this isn’t for me.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (13)

12. Spicy Zax Sauce

It’s not like I’d call this sauce gross, but it’s mentally off-putting. It’s such a deep orange color that you think there must be tons of flavor packed in, but … there’s just nothing. Where is it? Where is the flavor? It’s really throwing me off. This is a waste of everybody’s time.

This article was originally published on Cheapism

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (14)

More From Cheapism

Like Cheapism's content? Be sure to follow us.

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1 (2024)

FAQs

I Tried and Ranked 12 of Zaxby’s Sauces, and Zax Sauce Was Not #1? ›

Best: Sweet and Spicy Sauce

Zaxby's has cooked up a tasty one; sweet as honey, spicy enough to even it out, and threaded together by a healthy dose of sesame oil. Umami all around. There's not a lot I wouldn't dip into this. It's the best Zaxby's sauce by a mile.

What is the best sauce at Zaxby's? ›

Best: Sweet and Spicy Sauce

Zaxby's has cooked up a tasty one; sweet as honey, spicy enough to even it out, and threaded together by a healthy dose of sesame oil. Umami all around. There's not a lot I wouldn't dip into this. It's the best Zaxby's sauce by a mile.

Why doesn't Zaxby's have insane sauce anymore? ›

Early in 2022 Zaxbys removed "Insane Sauce" from its list of available sauces. This decision has brought pain to many. In what appears to be an attempt to cut costs, Zaxbys did what it did... however, this can not stand.

What sauce did Zaxby's get rid of? ›

Why Did Zaxbys Remove Insane Sauce | TikTok. I need to go back home.

What does Zax sauce taste like? ›

Zax sauce is spicy, creamy, and really good with fried chicken, chicken fingers, and sandwiches. It's a great alternative to traditional BBQ sauce. If you are a fan of Zaxby's Zax sauce, this copycat recipe is for you! I like to add a full teaspoon of black pepper but you can add as much as you like.

What is Zaxby's sauce similar to? ›

What does Zax sauce taste like? The taste of this sauce has been described as a cross between honey mustard and ketchup that has a creamy texture.

Does Zax sauce need to be refrigerated? ›

How long does Zax Sauce last? The sauce should stay fresh for at least five days in the fridge. Since the Zaxby's Sauce recipe contains mayo, it shouldn't be at room temperature for longer than 20 or 30 minutes to prevent spoilage.

Is Zax sauce discontinued? ›

Zaxby's on X: "We're sorry to announce that we're getting rid of Zax Sauce." / X.

Why did Zaxby's stop making milkshakes? ›

In 2017, the brand posted to X, formerly known as Twitter, "Sadly, we are discontinuing our milkshakes because it was time for the boys to leave the yard." Without further explanation or plans to bring the milkshakes back, Zaxby's left devotees less than amused.

What did Zaxbys used to be called? ›

Zaxby's founders and childhood friends Zach McLeroy and Tony Townley opened the very first Zaxby's — originally called ZAX — with the simple goal of serving only the highest quality food in a fun environment. The concept, one of the earliest premium quick-service restaurants, proved successful.

Did Zaxby's get rid of fried pickles? ›

In 2022, Zaxby's announced that its Fried Pickles are here to stay and made the fan favorite a permanent menu item. Zaxby's serves fresh, prepared-at-order Chicken Fingerz® and wings tossed in a variety of bold and spicy sauces.

Which Zaxby's sauce is buffalo? ›

Zaxby's launches new Buffalo Garlic Blaze sauce with off-beat ad campaign | Zaxby's.

Is Chick Fil A sauce like Zax sauce? ›

The Zax Sauce also tastes strange, and similar to Chick-fil-A's sauce, except not as satisfying as the chicken. Whenever I order from Zaxby's, I dip their chicken into Chick-fil-A's signature sauce or Polynesian sauce, because it tastes better that way. I prefer the stronger flavor.

Is Cane's sauce Zax sauce? ›

While the Zaxby's sauce looks almost the same as Cane's sauce, the Zaxby's sauce is incredibly bitter and completely over powers the taste of chicken.

Is Zax sauce Thousand Island? ›

Its fans also cite it as “unique,” but online commenters agree that it's similar to Thousand Island dressing—a blend of mayo, ketchup and chopped pickles or pickle relish. Zaxby's special Zax Sauce landed in the No. 3 spot.

What is a most popular at Zaxby's? ›

What Is the Most Popular Meal at Zaxby's?
  • Zaxby's Club Sandwich Meal. ...
  • Nibblerz Meal. ...
  • Zalad Boxed Lunch. ...
  • Zaxby's Cobb Salad. ...
  • Buffalo Big Zax Snak Meal. ...
  • Boneless Wings Meal. ...
  • Traditional Wings & Things. ...
  • -1. Kickin' Chicken Sandwich Meal.
Jun 2, 2024

What is Zaxby's wimpy sauce like? ›

The aptly named Wimpy offers a training wheels version of a Buffalo sauce. Catch some cayenne and a hint of Tabasco while setting this sauce out for everyone afraid to quaff copious quantities of beer to put out the mouth fires.

What sauce is on Zaxby's chicken sandwich? ›

Hand-breaded Chicken Fillet, dill pickles, and Zax Sauce® on a toasted potato bun.

What is tongue torch sauce at Zaxby's? ›

What is Zaxby's Tongue Torch Sauce? Zaxby's Tongue Torch Sauce is a delicious spicy sauce that you can find at Zaxby's restaurants. Many people love it and even order their meals just because of it, It's creamy, tangy, and has a delicious spicy taste that anyone loves spicy tastes will love it for sure.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Edmund Hettinger DC

Last Updated:

Views: 6000

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Edmund Hettinger DC

Birthday: 1994-08-17

Address: 2033 Gerhold Pine, Port Jocelyn, VA 12101-5654

Phone: +8524399971620

Job: Central Manufacturing Supervisor

Hobby: Jogging, Metalworking, Tai chi, Shopping, Puzzles, Rock climbing, Crocheting

Introduction: My name is Edmund Hettinger DC, I am a adventurous, colorful, gifted, determined, precious, open, colorful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.